ISSN: 2456–5474 RNI No.  UPBIL/2016/68367 VOL.- VIII , ISSUE- X November  - 2023
Innovation The Research Concept
An  Appraisal  In  Regional  Imbalances  In  Health  Care  Facilities  Of  Purba  Medinipur  District,  West  Bengal
Paper Id :  18285   Submission Date :  12/11/2023   Acceptance Date :  23/11/2023   Publication Date :  25/11/2023
This is an open-access research paper/article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
DOI:10.5281/zenodo.10349140
For verification of this paper, please visit on http://www.socialresearchfoundation.com/innovation.php#8
Mahua Dutta
Assistant Professor
Department Of Geography
Gokhale Memorial Girls’ College, University Of Calcutta,
Kolkata,West Bengal, India
Abstract

Health care means the maintenance of human health by the means of prevention of diseases. At the same time it also emphasizes on the diagnosis, treatment, recovery of both the physical and mental impairments in people. State of physical, mental and social wellbeing is known as health. Good health results in a better quality of life. Economic growth leads people to live better and longer. Longer life expectancy encourages larger investments in human capital, which in turn accelerates the per capita income. Health service is an indicator of social development. The study on health care facilities of a region is a far more fruitful exercise towards planning for development.

Purba Medinipur district, located to the southern part of West Bengal, has better health care facilities as compared to the other districts of West Bengal or other states of India. This district has quite a handful number of hospitals, block primary health centres, primary health centres and nursing homes. The number of beds for patients in various medical institutions and the number of doctors present in the district also remain higher. However, it has been found that a slight regional imbalance in the health care sector is present in the district. On further analysis, all the 25 blocks and 5 municipalities have been grouped into surplus and deficit areas based on the availability of various medical services. The study reveals a significant amount of disparity in the distribution of health services in Purba Medinipur district. This type of disparity create regional imbalances and hinders the all round development of an area. Proper planning is required for equal distribution of medical facilities and health services.

Keywords Health Care, Prevention Of Diseases, Social Wellbeing, Economic Growth, Social Development, Quality of Life, Regional Imbalance, Surplus And Deficit, Disparity.
Introduction

Development leads to advancement and it is used to describe the process of economic and social transformation. Development means the evolution of society from one state to another and more control over its environment. Economic growth does not ensure development and hence true development has to emerge from within the society – neither can be borrowed from elsewhere nor can it be imposed.

Aim of study

Objectives of this paper are to study-

1. Spatio-temporal variation of different health care facilities of Purba Medinipur district

2. Spatial variation of health services among different blocks and municipalities of the district

3. The regional disparity in health care sector of the district.

Review of Literature

Goulet (1971) highlighted three basic components in development: (i) life sustenance, (ii) self esteem and (iii) freedom. The basic needs concept was initiated in the 70s by the World Bank which aims for housing, clothing, food and minimal education for all. Hence, development means to elevate poverty and at the same time provide basic needs, to promote a social order where none is oppressed, nor is there an oppressor.

Economic growth leads people to live longer and better and enjoy good health. According to World Health Organisation (WHO), health care facilities are hospitals, primary health care entres, isolation camps, burn patient units, feeding centres and others. Health services are considered as one of the most important criteria of human development index. Good health results in a better quality of life. Higher income leads to better health and sanitation but better health and sanitation also leads to higher income because of increased productivity and labour force participation.

Methodology

The study is based on the secondary data collected from the District Census Handbook, Census of India, 2011 and from the office of Deputy Chief Medical Officer of Health, Purba medinipur. The district and block-wise data for health services (hospitals, rural hospitals, block primary health centre, primary health centres and nursing homes) have been collected, tabulated and mapped.  Data on Universal Immunization Programmes for various years have also been collected. Number of people served by various health facilities have been calculated and mapped.

Score values of the whole district and the blocks and municipalities of the district have been calculated and analysed. On the basis of these values, residual score values for the blocks have been found out. The surplus and deficit blocks in terms of health facilities have been calculated and tabulated.
Statistics Used in the Study

Location of The Study Area

The district of Purba Medinipur is situated between 210 38’ north and 220 30’ north latitude, and 870 27’ east and 880 11’ east longitudes.  The youngest district emerged on 1st January, 2002 from former undivided Midnapore. This newly created 19th district has an area of 4295 square kilometers (District Statistical Handbook, 2005) and has a population of about 5095875 (2011 census) with a density of 1028 persons per square kilometer. The district comprises of 4 subdivisions, 21 police stations and 25 Community Development Blocks and 5 Municipalities, with the district headquarter at Tamluk – the much known Tamralipta port of the Gupta Age.


Source: NATMO and Census of India, 2011 
Fig. 1

Analysis

Health care facilities

Medical facilities available in the district of Purba Medinipur have been shown in Table-1. It is seen that the number of hospitals, rural hospitals, block primary health centres and primary health centres in the district remained the same from 2010 to 2014, although, there was a little increase in the number of nursing homes during this year. The numbers of nursing homes have been decreased from 177 in 2013 to 132 in 2014. This is because some nursing homes have not got renewal license certificate from the health department of West Bengal as they could not fulfill the criteria set by the government.


In all these medical centres the total number of beds has grown from 3416 to 3486 which accounts only 2.1 percent growth in these five years. Total number of doctors available in the

district increased from 258 in 2010 to 295 in 2014. Therefore, it may be said that the medical facilities in the study area are not satisfactory according to the present population scenario.

Table-2. Achievement of Universal Immunization Programme In The District Of Purba Medinipur, 2009-10 to 2013-14

YEAR

NUMBER OF CASES

TT

DPT

POLIO

BCG

MEASLES

2009-10

78035

86755

84408

89338

82654

2010-11

83315

81993

83454

91489

81537

2011-12

88058

86201

70179

91795

82180

2012-13

83200

85164

78116

87735

84723

2013-14

82988

82445

88355

88430

80232

Note : TT = Tetanus Toxoid     DPT = Diphtheria Pertussis Tetanus

BCG = Bacille Calmette Guerin

Source: Deputy C.M.O.H. - III, Purba Medinpur, 2014

Various Immunization Programmes help in the development of a region. Table-2 shows that from 2009-10 to 2013-14 quite a good number of populations was covered under TT, DPT, Polio, BCG and Measles immunizing programme. As more and more industries are coming up, with the increase in literacy level and consciousness of the mass population, the usefulness of various types of immunization has been realized and this in turn is improving the quality of life.


Fig. 4 depicts the scenario of the district wise available medical facilities at Block and Municipal level. The municipalities are provided with government hospitals which are known as Sadar Hospital. All the blocks have rural hospitals and primary health centres, set up by the government of West Bengal. It is interesting to note that only Ramnagar-I Block (Table-3) is provided with two government hospitals; one of which is located at the favourite tourist spot at Digha. These hospitals are equipped with good medicinal facilities and provide free treatment to the people. Huge number of nursing homes is located in the municipalities. Tamluk, being the district headquarters has the maximum number of nursing homes which cater to the medicare facilities to the people who come from the surrounding rural areas to the town for better treatment. Contai Municipality has the maximum number of doctors and Haldia Municipality has the maximum number of hospital beds for patients. The scenario is quite dissatisfying. More healthcare facilities are available in the northeastern part of the district while the western part and the interior are lagging behind.

Table-4. Number of Persons Per Medical Centre In Purba Medinipur District, 2014.

Name Of Blocks/ Municipality

Population

Number Of Medical Institutions

Number Of Persons Per Medical Institution

Tamluk

217776

6

36296

Sahid Matangini

199210

11

18110

Panskura

283303

9

31479

Kolaghat

290124

12

24177

Moyna

226927

5

45386

Nandakumar

262998

4

65750

Mahisadal

206277

5

41256

Nandigram I

207635

3

69212

Nandigram II

123219

3

41073

Chandipur

188119

11

17102

Sutahata

123784

6

20631

Haldia

97992

3

32664

Patashpur I

173377

5

34676

Patashpur II

175056

4

43764

Egra I

167163

4

41791

Egra II

178763

4

44691

Khejuri I

132992

2

66496

Khejuri II

139463

3

46488

Bhagwanpur I

234432

7

33491

Bhagwanpur II

192162

9

21352

Ramnagar I

167330

9

18593

Ramnagar II

156054

4

39014

Contai I

170894

3

56965

Deshapran

176393

3

58798

Contai III

157793

3

52598

Tamluk (M)

65306

32

2041

Haldia (M)

200827

15

13389

Egra (M)

30148

14

2154

Contai (M)

92226

12

7686

Panskura (M)

57932

2

28966

TOTAL

5095875

213

23925

Source:  District Census Hand Book, Midnapore, 2011, Dy. C.M.O.H. - II, Purba Medinipur, Super / Director of the respective hospitals, 2014 and calculated by the author

Fig. 5 shows the number of persons per medical centres in the study area. It is a fact that more the number of populations per medical institution less are the level of development in that region. It is surprising to see that 2000 people are treated in a single medical institution only in Tamluk and Egra Municipalities. Each hospital serves quite a high number of patients in Contai and Haldia Municipalities. The condition is worse in rest of the two Municipalities where around 15000 people and above is treated by a single medical institution.

Source: As in Table-4

Fig. 5

Table-5. Number of Hospital Beds per Thousand Populations in

Purba Medinipur District, 2014

Name of Blocks/ Municipality

Population

Number of Beds

Number of Beds Per Thousand Population

Tamluk

217776

65

0.298

Sahid Matangini

199210

115

0.577

Panskura

283303

110

0.388

Kolaghat

290124

145

0.499

Moyna

226927

50

0.220

Nandakumar

262998

50

0.190

Mahisadal

206277

80

0.388

Nandigram I

207635

46

0.221

Nandigram II

123219

165

1.339

Chandipur

188119

30

0.159

Sutahata

123784

115

0.929

Haldia

97992

20

0.204

Patashpur I

173377

40

0.231

Patashpur II

175056

40

0.228

Egra I

167163

20

0.119

Egra II

178763

50

0.279

Khejuri I

132992

40

0.301

Khejuri II

139463

48

0.344

Bhagwanpur I

234432

60

0.256

Bhagwanpur II

192162

95

0.339

Ramnagar I

167330

90

0.538

Ramnagar II

156054

30

0.192

Contai I

170894

25

0.146

Deshapran

176393

10

0.057

Contai III

157793

10

0.063

Tamluk (M)

65306

766

11.729

Haldia (M)

200827

512

2.549

Egra (M)

30148

279

9.254

Contai (M)

92226

34

0.369

Panskura (M)

57932

40

0.690

TOTAL

5095875

3486

0.684

Source:  District Census Hand Book, Midnapore, 2011, Dy. C.M.O.H. - II, Purba Medinipur, Super / Director of the respective hospitals, 2014 and calculated by the author.

The scenario is totally reversed in case of number of beds in medical institutions per thousand of population (Fig. 6). Three Municipalities are represented by more than one bed in hospitals for one thousand populations. Ramnagar-I and Nandigram-II Blocks too show a satisfactory level. Most of the Blocks are provided with 0.1 beds for one thousand populations or it may be said that only one bed in the hospitals are available for ten thousand populations. This is because all the primary health centres and most of the clinics present in the rural areas have only outdoor facilities.

Table-6. Number of doctors per lakh population in

Purba Medinipur district 2014

Name of Blocks/ Municipalty

Population

Number of Doctors

Number of Doctors Per Lakh Population

Tamluk

217776

4

1.8

Sahid Matangini

199210

8

4.0

Panskura

283303

7

2.5

Kolaghat

290124

7

2.4

Moyna

226927

3

1.3

Nandakumar

262998

10

3.8

Mahisadal

206277

8

3.9

Nandigram I

207635

9

4.3

Nandigram II

123219

10

3.5

Chandipur

188119

5

2.7

Sutahata

123784

6

4.8

Haldia

97992

5

5.1

Patashpur I

173377

4

2.3

Patashpur II

175056

6

3.4

Egra I

167163

6

3.6

Egra II

178763

4

2.2

Khejuri I

132992

6

4.5

Khejuri II

139463

4

2.9

Bhagwanpur I

234432

5

2.1

Bhagwanpur II

192162

4

2.1

Ramnagar I

167330

14

8.4

Ramnagar II

156054

11

7.0

Contai I

170894

7

4.1

Deshapran

176393

7

3.9

Contai III

157793

5

3.2

Tamluk (M)

65306

52

79.6

Haldia (M)

200827

29

14.4

Egra (M)

30148

17

56.4

Contai (M)

92226

30

32.5

Panskura (M)

57932

3

5.2

TOTAL

5095875

296

5.8

Source: District Census Hand Book, Midnapore, 2011, Dy. C.M.O.H. - II, Purba Medinipur, Super / Director of the   respective hospitals, 2014 and calculated by the author.

Source: As in Table-6

Fig. 7

Number of doctors per lakh of population (Fig. 7) is highest in the Municipalities. Here more than 5 doctors are available per lakh population which is very small. Ramnagar-I and II, Sutahata and Haldia Block have more or less 5 to 8 doctors for one lakh population. The availability of doctors in rest of the areas is very poor; only 2 to 4 doctors are available for each lakh of population. This is because due to better infrastructure and good medical facilities, doctors are eager to practice in the urban and more developed areas. Therefore, it may be said that apart from the five Municipalities of Tamluk, Haldia, Contai, Panskura and Egra, the Blocks of Ramnagar-I and II, Sutahata and Haldia are medically more advanced than the other areas of the district.

Score Values

Health services data on various items such as population, number of hospitals, block primary health  centres, primary health centres, nursing homes, number of doctors, number of beds available for  patients in the medical institutions of Purba Medinipur district have been taken into account to calculate total score values. For each item, number of population served by each variable is also calculated to determine the population threshold (Table-7). Considering the lowest threshold value as score point one (1), the scores of all the items of the whole district has been calculated (Table-7). The total scores for all the items are then calculated (Table-8). Finally the analysis of data has been done.

Table-7. Score Values of Health Services,Purba Medinipur district 2014

Sl. no.

Facilities

Absolute Number of Facilities

Population Threshold

Score

1

Hospitals

8

636985

435.7

2

Block Primary Health Centres

22

231631

158.4

3

Primary Health Centres

51

99920

68.3

4

Nursing Homes

132

38606

26.4

5

Doctors

293

17393

11.9

6

Beds

3486

1462

1.0

 Note: Total Population of the District (Census 2011) is 5095875

Source: District Census Hand Book, Midnapore, 2011, Dy. C.M.O.H. - II, Purba Medinipur, Super / Director of the   respective hospitals, 2014 and calculated by the author.


Based on the estimated score values and residual values (Table-9), surplus and deficit blocks and municipalities (Table-10) have been identified.

Table-9. Residual of Score Values on Population, Purba Medinipur, 2014

Name of Blocks/ Municipality

Population

In Thousand

(X)

Total Score (Y)

Estimated Score Valuse

(Ye)

Residual Values (Y-Ye)

Tamluk

217.776

468.8

497.349

-110.54

Sahid Matangini

199.210

716.4

635.224

+81.18

Panskura

283.303

646.7

463.675

+183.03

Kolaghat

290.124

760.9

449.47

+311.43

Moyna

226.927

433.5

578.68

-145.18

Nandakumar

262.998

490.4

505.24

-14.84

Mahisadal

206.277

758.4

620.807

+137.6

Nandigram I

207.635

448.1

617.629

-169.52

Nandigram II

123.219

721.3

790.246

-68.94

Chandipur

188.119

730.7

657.85

+72.85

Sutahata

123.784

534.2

789.093

-254.89

Haldia

97.992

374.5

841.709

-467.2

Patashpur I

173.377

393.5

687.923

-294.42

Patashpur II

175.056

432.8

684.498

-251.69

Egra I

167.163

412.8

700.600

-287.8

Egra II

178.763

460.9

676.936

-216.03

Khejuri I

132.992

338.1

770.309

-432.2

Khejuri II

139.463

348.7

757.108

-408.4

Bhagwanpur I

234.432

839.3

563.371

+275.93

Bhagwanpur II

192.162

596

649.602

-53.6

Ramnagar I

167.330

1161.2

700.259

+460.95

Ramnagar II

156.054

524.2

723.262

-199.06

Contai I

170.894

403.3

692.989

-289.68

Deshapran

176.393

388.3

681.771

-293.47

Contai III

157.793

364.5

719.715

-355.21

Tamluk (M)

65.306

2638.9

908.388

+1730.52

Haldia (M)

200.827

1662.4

631.925

+1030.48

Egra (M)

30.148

1260.2

980.081

+280.12

Contai (M)

92.226

1423.1

853.471

+569.63

Panskura (M)

57.932

92.8

923.431

-830.63

TOTAL

5095875

 

 

 

Source: District Census Hand Book, Midnapore, 2011, Dy. C.M.O.H. - II, Purba Medinipur, Super / Director of the   respective hospitals, 2014 and calculated by the author.

Table-10.  Surplus and Deficit Blocks and Municipalities of Purba Medinipur, 2014

Type (Weighted Score)

Surpuls

Deficit

VERY HIGH (> 900)

Tamluk (M), Haldia (M),

 

HIGH (600-900)

 

Pansura (M)

MODERATE (300-600)

Kolaghat, Ramnagar-I, Contai (M)

Haldia, Khejuri-I, Khejuri-II, Contai-III

LOW (<300)

Sahid Matangini, Panskura, Chandipur, Mahisadal, Bhagwanpur-I, Egra (M)

Egra-II, Bhagwanpur-II, Ramnagar-II, Contai-I, Deshapran

TOTAL

11

19

Source: District Census Hand Book, Midnapore, 2011, Dy. C.M.O.H. - II, Purba Medinipur, Super / Director of the   respective hospitals, 2014 and calculated by the author.

Source: As in Table-9 and 10

Fig. 8

Out of the total thirty (30) blocks and municipalities of Purba Medinipur district, (Fig-8) eleven (11) blocks and municipalities covering 36.6 percent of the district’s total population have surplus of health services. This denotes that these blocks have better health care facilities for their population. It can be aid that the number of people present in these blocks can avail the sufficient health facilities present there. 

All these blocks and municipalities are located more or less in the eastern portion of the district. Tamluk and Haldia Municipalities show the better surplus health conditions (Table-10) than the other blocks and municipalities of the district. Remaining nineteen (19) blocks and municipalities have deficiency of health services which indicates that the number of people and the available health facilities are not at par. The health facilities are insufficient in comparison to the number of people present in these blocks. These areas are confined particularly to the western and southern part of the district. As far as balanced development is concerned, deficit areas need proper additional facilities and government attention to fill up the health care gap.

Conclusion

The study reveals the regional disparity in the distribution of health care facilities in Purba Medinipur district. This type of disparity creates regional imbalances in the development of a district. Proper planning is required for equal distribution of health care services. Various facilities should be given in the deficit areas. As population is increasing at a manifold rate, it should also be kept in mind while extending medical help. Public consciousness and health education is required at every level. Women education in this respect will usher in a brighter prospect.

References

1. Chandna, R.C. (2000), Geography Of Population, Kalyani Publishers, Calcutta, p.2, p.32, p.208, p.210, p.215, p. 242, p.255, p.261.

2. District Human Development Report, Purba Medinipur, Development and Planning, West Bengal, Kolkata, 2009, Government of West Bengal.

3. Ghosh, A. (2010), “Disparity in Health Services in Paschim Medinipur, West Bengal”, Geographical Review of India, Vol.72, No.2, 2010, pp.162-169.

4. Goulet, D. (1971), “The cruel Choice: A New Cocept in the Theory of Development, New York.

5. Government of India, Primary Census Abstract 2011, New Delhi.

6. Government of West Bengal, Bureau of Applied Economics and Statistics, West Bengal (2015), Kolkata.

7. https://www.who.int/environmental_health_emergencies/services/en/

8. Khosla, R.K. (2000), Rural and Urban development In India, Indian Publishers and Distributors, New Delhi, pp.10-11.

9. Mandal, A. (2017), Inequality in Health Services: A Case Stydy of South 24 Parganas District, West Bengal, India, International Journal of Innovative Research in Science, Engineering and Technology, Vol. 6, Issue 9, September 2017

10. Malley, L.S.S.O’. (Reprint 1995), Bengal District Gazetteers, Midnapore, West Bengal District Gazetteers, Government of West Bengal, Calcutta, pp.58-67.

11. Thirlwall, A.P. (1994), Growth and Development, fifth Edition, MacMillan Press Ltd, London, p.143.

12. Tyagi, Nutan (2006), Quality Of Life of Industrial Workers: A Case Study of Gorakhpur Region, Indian Journal of Landscape System and Ecological Studies, Institute of Landscape, Ecology and Ekistics, Kolkata, Vol.29 (1), June, 2006, pp.82-84.